Sonarcloud report and sonarlint connected mode with sonarcloud reports are different

SonarCloud
,
#1

Using sonarlint (Bind to sonarcloud) in Eclipse, I executed sonarcloud rules in my Java project, and I ran the results through the command prompt to produce the report. However, the two reports are not identical; additional sonar problems are shown in SonarCloud.

Command prompt : mvn verify org.sonarsource.scanner.maven:sonar-maven-plugin:sonar -Dsonar.host.url=https://sonarcloud.io -Dsonar.organization=XXX -Dsonar.login=XXXX -Dsonar.projectKey=XXX -Dsonar.projectName=XXX

Sonarscanner version :

<dependency>
    <groupId>org.sonarsource.scanner.maven</groupId>
    <artifactId>sonar-maven-plugin</artifactId>
    <version>3.9.1.2184</version>
</dependency>

Eclipse version : 2021-12 (4.22.0)
SonarLint : 7.4

Can anyone please help me here?

#3

Hello @Riya,

This can happen for a few reasons, could you check our FAQ and see if you fall into one of the cases ?

If it’s not the case, could you send us:

  • one of the rule for which you observe an issue on SonarCloud and not in SonarLint
  • a simple reproducer project that demonstrates the problem

Thanks!

#6

Hello @Damien_Urruty ,
Thanks for your reply. I am seeing the rule repository is sonarqube.

  • List item

  1. Below rule is showing in sonarcloud but not showing in sonarlint in connected mode.
    static" base class members should not be accessed via derived types

    image
    image1908×274 38.2 KB

  2. Below rule is showing in sonarlint in connected mode but not showing sonarcloud.
    Lambdas should be replaced with method references
    SonarCloud :

    image
    image1194×163 13.5 KB

    Sonarlint report from eclipse

    image
    image694×62 4.28 KB

    Java version :

    image
    image746×153 5.99 KB

Could you please help me here?

#8

Hi,

Can you provide a reproducer? I.e. code we can use to reproduce the problem?

 
Thx,
Ann

#9

@ganncamp , Here is the code.

first build this code

https://github.com/riya160791/parent/tree/master

then build :
https://github.com/riya160791/child/tree/master

then run the mvn scanner command in CMD.

#11

@Damien_Urruty & @ganncamp - can I get an update please?

#12

Hi,

Thanks for the files. The language experts need to take a look at this. Hopefully they’ll be along soon.

 
Ann

#13

@ganncamp Can I get an update?

#14

@ganncamp any update on this? I am waiting for your reply.

#16

Hi S Riya,

I was about to try to reproduce your problem using the two GitHub repositories that you mentioned. But I saw a bin folder in each of them with some .class files. I don’t want to build a project that contains a file that I can not check before. I don’t understand why you add in GitHub the .class versions of your java files. I don’t understand why your maven configurations is duplicated in those bin folders. I don’t understand why this pom.xml file contains a typo, a F at the beginning of the XML file that make it invalid.

#17

@alban.auzeill - It was my mistake. I hope you will not face any issue now, I have corrected. Can you please reproduce the problem and let me know

#18

Can i get update?