We are in the process of evaluating SonarCloud in comparison to our current, on-prem SonarQube and am having issues with request analysis. Specifically with inline comments. The analysis completes successfully and the Pull Request check shows up in GitHub (with a failed status), however I do not s…

We would also love to have this feature back. It significantly improves code quality & productivity by showing everything there is to a PR to a developer. There’s no way they’ll forget to go through the reported issues.

Registered to say that my team shares the same sentiment: SonarCloud is barely helpful and completely unnoticed without inline comments.

I am currently evaluating code quality tools for my team and I was just about to go with SonarCloud as it matches our code base and security requirements better than Codacy and Code Climate. However, finding that the most useful feature has been removed is incredibly disappointing. I concur with the…

Where are we at with this, SonarCloud team? To be very clear, this is the main issue stopping us from deepening our SonarQube implementation, and will be the #1 reason we will churn off the platform to another product. Inline comments are perfectly fine - please don’t get hung up on the Annotations …

This is also important to my team. We are currently a Codacy customer, and find that this feature delivers a lot of value. We would be interested to re-consider SonarCloud if and when this feature is re-enabled.

Annotations or comments are such great feature. I’m impressed that SonarCloud currently doesn’t support it;

That’s great news! Are you targeting this in a current or far future release?

Hi, do you have any estimation when we can have inline comments again? :upside_down_face:

We were evaluating sonarqube developer edition 8.1.0, the main reason for us to move from community editon to developer edition was pull request decoration feature. So can we know from which version this feature was removed/issue has been started?, so that I can downgrade to that version to get th…

SonarCloud + GitHub + Pull Request Analysis = No Inline Comments

SonarQube Cloud

benoit (Benoit) October 23, 2019, 12:31pm 35

Hi everyone,

Just to let you know that we’re currently looking at this.
We’re going to provide a way to see SonarCloud issues in diff of GitHub PR, either by annotations or comments.

Thanks!

Topic		Replies	Views
Sonarcloud comments don't show on Github Pull Requests SonarQube Cloud	4	1478	October 7, 2022
Issue with sonarqube pull request decoration integration with GitHub SonarQube Server / Community Build sonarqube , github , pull-request , github-checks	8	3302	May 12, 2020
Disable GitHub Merge Request comments SonarQube Cloud github , pull-request , github-checks , sonarqube-cloud	32	13146	July 22, 2020
Pull request decoration did not happen for BitbucketCloud SonarQube Cloud bitbucket , pull-request	30	6867	December 6, 2021
PR analysis results are now displayed in the Checks tab of Pull Requests in GitHub Announcements github-checks , sonarqube-cloud	16	12847	December 11, 2020

SonarCloud + GitHub + Pull Request Analysis = No Inline Comments

Related topics