We are in the process of evaluating SonarCloud in comparison to our current, on-prem SonarQube and am having issues with request analysis. Specifically with inline comments. The analysis completes successfully and the Pull Request check shows up in GitHub (with a failed status), however I do not s…

@janos That seems foolish. That was one of the biggest selling-points of using SonarCloud vs other scan services when we did an analysis last year. Can we expect the Sonar-injected comments in the Conversations tab to come back in the future?

It seems the Conversation tab is intended for content by humans, not by robots. For that reason we don’t have plans to go back on that route. It seems Checks is the way to go for such automated checks that we do. We are considering to enrich the feature in that direction.

Although I appreciate that conversations are better for humans, there is already extensive precedence for robot actions being annotated in that view. Furthermore, it is of massive value to get an automated GitHub “Review” from SonarCloud, and it would be good to use GitHub’s functionality for displa…

[image] lewiso: it is of massive value to get an automated GitHub “Review” from SonarCloud, and it would be good to use GitHub’s functionality for displaying that. As @janos said, Checks functionality is now the way GitHub expects external integrations like SonarCloud to contribute informatio…

[image] Fabrice_Bellingard: Can you clarify what makes users think that the PR decoration is done through comments instead of checks? The documentation does not mention comments - so I’m a bit confused. I believe this line is misleading. automatically decorate your PRs with SonarCloud issu…

[image] lewiso: Have you migrated to GitHub annotations, or is it an error in my configuration that means I am not seeing annotations/inline decorations? I guess you might have missed the following part in PR analysis results are now displayed in the Checks tab of Pull Requests in GitHub : A…

[image] Fabrice_Bellingard: I guess you might have missed the following part in PR analysis results are now displayed in the Checks tab of Pull Requests in GitHub : Correct, I missed that. That only makes me more disappointed that you thought about it and chose not to use it. This has quite a…

[image] lewiso: This change puts us in a tough position. I’d like to dig into why you think this puts you in a tough position. With the quality gate summary and the links available in the SonarCloud Check page, you get the big picture of the quality of the PR and can get access (through the l…

@Fabrice_Bellingard I think a simple way to explain it is that ideally you want your developers to stay in a simplistic workflow. I went to Atlassian’s talk at AWS Re:Invent 2 years ago where they explained how they thought you should use github hooks to push Jira tickets to sequential states so tha…

SonarCloud + GitHub + Pull Request Analysis = No Inline Comments

SonarQube Cloud

janos (Janos Gyerik) March 1, 2019, 6:41am 2

Indeed we have removed all comments from the Conversation tab. See this announcement.

Topic		Replies	Views
Sonarcloud comments don't show on Github Pull Requests SonarQube Cloud	4	1477	October 7, 2022
Issue with sonarqube pull request decoration integration with GitHub SonarQube Server / Community Build sonarqube , github , pull-request , github-checks	8	3299	May 12, 2020
Disable GitHub Merge Request comments SonarQube Cloud github , pull-request , github-checks , sonarqube-cloud	32	13140	July 22, 2020
Pull request decoration did not happen for BitbucketCloud SonarQube Cloud bitbucket , pull-request	30	6865	December 6, 2021
PR analysis results are now displayed in the Checks tab of Pull Requests in GitHub Announcements github-checks , sonarqube-cloud	16	12845	December 11, 2020

SonarCloud + GitHub + Pull Request Analysis = No Inline Comments

Related topics