.NET Analysis always has warning "Architecture analysis executed with errors"

SonarQube Cloud
, ,
1
  • ALM used: Azure DevOps
  • CI system used: Azure DevOps
  • Scanner command used when applicable: SonarCloudAnalyze@4 (with scannerMode: 'dotnet' in SonarCloudPrepare@4)
  • Languages of the repository: C#, JSON, XML, YAML
  • Only if the SonarCloud project is public, the URL: private
  • Error observed: See below
  • Steps to reproduce: See below
  • Potential workaround: Unknown

Since Architecture Analysis was introduced some time ago all my .NET projects now show a warning for all analysis runs. The warning is:

Architecture analysis executed with errors. Analysis results may be incomplete or invalid.

How do I get rid of this warning? I do not want or need Architecture analysis.

Here are the log lines that contain the word “architecture” from the SonarCloudAnalyze@4 task of a sample run:

INFO: Loaded core extensions: a3s, architecture, sca
[...]
INFO: Sensor CSharpArchitectureSensor [architecture]
INFO: Found 1 potential Udg file location(s) for "cs" in "D:\a\1\.sonarqube\out"
INFO: - D:\a\1\.sonarqube\out\architecture\cs
INFO: Architecture analysis is enabled with the following features: legacy, discovery, flaws, smells, deviations, directives
INFO: * Protobuf reading starting | memory total=264 | free=123 | used=140 (MB)
INFO: * Reading SonarArchitecture UDG data from directory "D:\a\1\.sonarqube\out\architecture\cs"
WARNING: WARN: Skipping load of file: "D:\a\1\.sonarqube\out\architecture\cs\14.1.udg"
WARNING: WARN: Error raised: 'other' has different root
WARNING: WARN: Skipping load of file: "D:\a\1\.sonarqube\out\architecture\cs\15.1.udg"
WARNING: WARN: Error raised: 'other' has different root
WARNING: WARN: Skipping load of file: "D:\a\1\.sonarqube\out\architecture\cs\17.1.udg"
WARNING: WARN: Error raised: 'other' has different root
WARNING: WARN: Skipping load of file: "D:\a\1\.sonarqube\out\architecture\cs\18.1.udg"
WARNING: WARN: Error raised: 'other' has different root
WARNING: WARN: Skipping load of file: "D:\a\1\.sonarqube\out\architecture\cs\6.1.udg"
WARNING: WARN: Error raised: 'other' has different root
WARNING: WARN: Skipping load of file: "D:\a\1\.sonarqube\out\architecture\cs\7.1.udg"
WARNING: WARN: Error raised: 'other' has different root
WARNING: WARN: Skipping load of file: "D:\a\1\.sonarqube\out\architecture\cs\8.1.udg"
WARNING: WARN: Error raised: 'other' has different root
WARNING: WARN: Skipping load of file: "D:\a\1\.sonarqube\out\architecture\cs\9.1.udg"
WARNING: WARN: Error raised: 'other' has different root
INFO: * Files successfully loaded: "10" out of "18"
INFO: * Purging externals (components not scanned) from graphs
INFO: * Purging excluded nodes from graphs
INFO: * Protobuf reading complete | memory total=264 | free=116 | used=147 (MB)
INFO: * Build architecture.graph.cs.namespace_graph.default_perspective hierarchy graph complete (filtered=false) | memory total=264 | free=103 | used=160 (MB)
INFO: No directives configured
INFO: * No intended architecture defined or detected, using an empty model
INFO: Sensor CSharpArchitectureSensor [architecture] (done) | time=7201ms
INFO: Sensor Zero Coverage Sensor
INFO: Sensor Zero Coverage Sensor (done) | time=8ms
INFO: Sensor Architecture Telemetry [architecture]
INFO: Sensor Architecture Telemetry [architecture] (done) | time=1ms
[...]
INFO: Successfully sent architecture data
2

Architecture scanning can be disabled with sonar.architecture.enable=false.

3

Good to know, thanks!

Assume I do want Architecture Analysis, how do I get rid of those errors/warnings?

4

Can you please add /d:sonar.verbose=true, send the debug log, and we will investigate. Thanks!

5

Thanks for the offer! But since I’m not sure if the full debug log contains any confidental information, I’d like to share it privately. How do I do that? It looks like the private message feature is disabled here?

Btw, I also checked your FAQ (linked at the top of the community page) about that question, but it also doesn’t answer how to share something privately.

6

Since I don’t know where to send private logs, I’ve now redacted the log. Please take a look at it:
Scanner Task Log.txt (1.2 MB)

7

Thanks @Manuel.P, we will investigate and come back to you.

8

Hi, any updates on this? We are experiencing the same issue as Manuel, running Sonar on AzureDevOps Pipelines with SonarCloudAnalyze@4 Disabled architecture analysis for now, but would like to see updates on this issue.

9

Hi @pauliusjasenas, the issue is in the queue. Thanks for flagging. We will post an update here once fixed.

10

Hi @Manuel.P and @pauliusjasenas an update has now been posted that addresses your issue in our test pipelines. I would be grateful if you can confirm the issue is resolved your end. Thanks!

11

Thanks @paul.hickey! It looks like the architecture warnings in the SonarCloudAnalyze@4 task are gone.

But the SonarQube Cloud web UI still showed the yellow warning box for me after running a PR build/analysis, even when I was on the “Summary” page for the PR analysis. I had to run a new main branch build/analysis, only then the yellow warning box was removed for all “Summary” pages.

12

Hi, I can confirm that the warnings are gone. Thank you for your help!