Commented code rule

Clean Code Report False-positive / False-negative...
#1

Hi everyone,

I have problem with commented code rule,

I’m sure in another versions of Quality Profiles, exists a rule for lines of code commented. But in my current versión of SonarCloud. I only have “Sections of code should not be commented out”, so when I have line commented, Sonar don’t detected (the rule works in sections or blocks, but the “problem” is in the logic lines of code commented).

Thanks and greetings!

#2

Hey there.

Can you share a sample of code where a single line is commented out and not detected? The rule is not precious about the number of lines (and a single line counts as a “section”) :slight_smile:

#3

Hi Colin, thanks for your answer.

For example:

public static boolean validToken(string idNumber) {
   String idToken = Util.getTokenById(idNumber);
   if(idToken != null) { // || idToken != "") {
     //system.out.println(idToken);
   }
   return idToken;
}

I this days I checked the issues is detected, sometimes, in code like:

String error = Util.convertToJson(ex.getStatusText(), Example.class) // gson.FromJson(ex.getStatus(), Error.class)