So this seemed to have resolved on its own…This has been a weird experience.
I even created a new local instance of SonarQube in a completely different folder on my C drive. For some reason, it was which was picking up the properties for my older SonarQube instance when I ran it in CommandPrompt (I definitely had the correct path to StartSonar.bat). I was expecting the new instance to throw an error about java since the wrapper.conf wasn’t even mapped correctly to it.
Just…weird.
I’ll be closing this question.